Okay, so I wasn’t expecting to be happy when I saw the headline of Topless Robot (an LA Weekly blog) Ten Reasons No One Cares About Wonder Woman but writer Alicia Ashby disarms me right at the beginning:
In fact, here are ten reasons why nobody really cares about Wonder Woman, even if they say they do. At best, people care about all the things that Wonder Woman could be, but isn’t, thanks to the character’s long history of editorial mismanagement, bizarrely bad writing, and a near-total lack of focus.
Okay, as someone who has repeatedly started and then dropped Wonder Woman that does resonate. I do love the concept but it’s hard to find someone who can do it justice — and that includes her biggest fans like Phil Jiminez. (Though I certainly did enjoy Greg Rucka’s run until it became wrapped into various big events.)
Oh, and, despite all the praise, there’s always something that leaves me cold when I try to sample the George Perez run.
And Ashby’s first issue with Wonder Woman is an interesting point:
In the ’40s, a woman in short-shorts was telling you she was no housewife! She was going to go out and do all kinds of unladylike things that involved exercise and possibly building muscle. In the 90’s, a woman who’s rolling into battle wearing a leotard resembles… um… nothing so much as an extremely angry underwear model.
For the most part, however, the rest of Ashby’s problems tend to come down to William Moutlon Marston’s stories being terrible and giving no good foundation for any later writers to build on. While I agree, there are plenty of problems current Wonder Woman has to deal with, I think Ashby overlooks the bigger problem. Moulton Marston was rare as a feminist writer of superhero comics and in the history of superhero comics there have been very few writers who understand feminism enough to write a Wonder Woman who continued the feminist themes while fixing the badly written stuff like the bondage obsession.
I certainly think the character can be worth caring about but you really need to keep writers like John Bryne, who are terrible at writing women, from writing Wonder Woman. The title also probably needs to have a moratorium on any more stories about how another writer’s idea was crap and the current writer knows how it should be done. Seriously, we don’t need any more attempts to make the Invisible Plane make sense so just stop trying.
Too bad there are so few good superhero writers, much less good superhero writers who write a good superheroine. Still, that would be why I’m looking forward to seeing the first Gail Simone trade come out.
I have a new favorite lesbian comedian:
Er... uhm...:
Uhm, what?:
Unity:
ZOMG! Called it!: